27 Things a Mobile Number Reveals: Signals for Fraud, KYC and Leads
A mobile number exposes 27 signals, from country and network to SIM swap, network KYC, device changes and location. What each one shows and where it fails.
Key findings
- A mobile number is more than a contact detail. It opens 27 separate signals about the number, the line, the subscriber, the device and its location.
- Four come from the number itself. The rest come from the mobile network, and many need permissions and the subscriber’s consent.
- A number that is still out of network after three checks across 16 hours has about a 7% chance of ever becoming live again. Recheck it, then reject it.
- Mobile network KYC checks name, date of birth and address against the operator’s own contract records. Its weakness is coverage: smaller networks and pay-as-you-go are often missing.
- Each signal is worth more across many numbers than on one. Patterns seen in past numbers, tied to what happened next, are what expose a new one.
Summary assessment
Most people treat a mobile number as a way to be reached. To a mobile network it is a key to a record: who holds the contract, for how long, on what device, and where that device is.
This file lists 27 things that can be established from a mobile number, alone or with a few other details. Four can be read from the number. The rest are held by the network. Many are released only to parties with the right agreements and the subscriber’s consent.
Source: high. Simon Delaney reports from first-hand testing of these signals. Background in lead generation, identity, verification and software for data processing.
Scope: not every signal exists in every country or on every network. The list is the full range across all of them, and it is growing. The source expects it to pass 30 within months.
Evidence: published for at least 15 of the 27 signals, which correspond to mobile industry standards, listed below. Stated for the rest and for the two findings under Evidence. Contact source for evidence. The figures in those findings are recalled from memory and are approximate. Each finding comes from one setting.
The 27 signals
From the number alone
- Country. The country code shows where the number was issued, such as +44 for the UK. It does not show where the person is.
- Original network. The operator the number was first allocated to.
- Validity. Correct format, prefix and length. This is a syntax check. It does not show whether the number is in use.
- Number type. Mobile, landline or VoIP. A VoIP number where a mobile is expected is a fraud signal, and it affects whether a text will arrive.
From the network
- Current network. The operator hosting the number today, after any move from the original. Returned by an HLR lookup.
- Porting history. The previous networks, the number of moves and their dates. Constant switching is not how most people behave.
- Network tenure. How long the number has been with its network. Ten years on one contract is a stronger identity signal than ten days.
- Contract type. Pay monthly or pay as you go.
- Roaming. Whether the device is connected abroad. A phone in another country during a UK mortgage application is worth a question. The applicant may also be on holiday.
About the subscriber
- Age threshold. True or false: is the subscriber over a stated age, such as 18, 21 or 50?
- Date of birth. True or false: does the supplied date of birth match the one the network holds?
- Subscriber name. Whether the name on the mobile account matches the name given on an application.
From registers
- Breach exposure. Whether the number appears in known breaches, how recently and how often. Coverage is thinner than for email addresses, and many results trace to one large Facebook breach. In aggregate it is useful. A batch of numbers that all appear in breaches points to a stolen file being submitted by a bot.
- Marketing suppression. Whether the number is on a do-not-call register, such as the Telephone Preference Service in the UK.
Takeover and identity
- SIM swap. Whether the SIM was recently replaced. Criminals move a number to their own SIM to intercept banking codes and two-factor messages.
- Mobile network KYC. Whether the supplied name, date of birth and address match the operator’s records. The answer is true, false or a match score.
- Live, dead or out of network. The current status of the number, where the country’s networks report it.
Device and location
- Location verification. True or false: is the device within a stated radius of a given point? The check is made by the network and does not rely on GPS.
- Number recycling. Whether the number has been reassigned to a new subscriber, who could receive the previous owner’s recovery codes.
- Silent verification. Proof that the person holds the number, with no text message sent.
- Device swap. The same number in a different handset. Relevant before an account recovery or a transaction.
- Call forwarding. Whether incoming calls are being diverted. A risk if sensitive information is given by phone.
- Device identification. The manufacturer and model, and whether the handset has changed.
- Device reachability. Whether the device can receive a text or use mobile data at this moment.
Combined
- Fraud risk score. Tenure, SIM changes, device activity and breach exposure taken together. The signals say more in combination than alone.
- Identity retrieval. The operator’s own record of name, date of birth and address, returned to pre-fill an application. This needs specific permissions and consent. It is not open to a marketer who wants a shorter form.
- Geofencing. An alert when a device enters or leaves a defined area.
Corroboration: published standards
Status: corroborated for at least 15 of the 27.
The mobile industry publishes these capabilities as standard network interfaces under the GSMA Open Gateway initiative and the CAMARA project. The published names map to the list as follows:
- Number Verification: signal 20
- SIM Swap: 15
- Device Swap: 21
- Call Forwarding Signal: 22
- Know Your Customer Match: 16, and the name and date of birth checks in 11 and 12
- Know Your Customer Age Verification: 10
- Know Your Customer Fill-In: 26
- Know Your Customer Tenure: 7, with contract type, 8, as an optional output
- Number Recycling: 19
- Location Verification: 18
- Geofencing: 27
- Device Roaming Status: 9
- Device Reachability Status: 24
- Device Identifier: 23
One detail from the standards bears on signal 7. Tenure is measured with the current provider and resets when a number is ported. A short tenure may mean a new customer or a recent switch. Porting history, signal 6, tells the two apart.
Evidence: two findings
Finding 1: out of network numbers
Status: first-hand testing. Figures recalled from memory.
A number that returns as out of network leaves the buyer unsure what to do. Rejecting it on a form may turn away someone whose mobile is their only phone. So it is accepted, passed to a call centre and dialled again and again.
The source’s team rechecked out of network numbers over time.
- Method: three checks across 16 hours.
- Result: a number still out of network at the end had about a 7% chance of ever becoming live again.
Reading: out of network is treated as a temporary state. For most numbers that stay there, it is permanent. The ambiguity is useful cover for anyone feeding dead numbers into a call centre, because nobody is sure enough to reject them.
Action: do not take the status at face value. Recheck several times over a set period. Reject what has not come back.
Finding 2: contract type against a credit score
Status: first-hand, one client, some years ago. Figures recalled from memory.
A mobile phone company was using a score from a major credit reference agency to predict which applicants would pass its credit check. The score was right about half the time. The source’s team tested contract type, pay monthly against pay as you go, as a predictor. As recalled, it reached about 67%.
Reading: in that case a single network signal did better than a commercial demographic score. It does not mean a pay-as-you-go customer will fail a credit check. It is one signal, in one setting.
Limits
- Geography. Signals differ by country.
- Network. Not every operator provides every signal. Smaller networks are often absent.
- Pay as you go. Mobile network KYC depends on a contract. Pay-as-you-go numbers are usually not covered.
- Permission and consent. Age, identity, location and device signals are released only to authorised parties, for defined purposes, with the subscriber’s consent.
- Signals are not verdicts. A roaming phone may be a holiday. A new SIM may be an upgrade. Each signal prompts a question.
Mobile network KYC and commercial KYC data
Commercial KYC checks query large compiled databases. The records in them may be old, breached or synthetic, and nobody can say how widely a given record has been shared. See where commercial KYC data comes from.
Mobile network KYC asks a different party. The operator holds a contract with the subscriber and is asked whether the name, address and date of birth supplied match its own records for that number. The source rates it as a strong and often very accurate check. Its weakness is coverage.
One number and many
On a single application, these signals test whether the person is who they claim to be and whether the number is safely theirs.
Across hundreds of thousands or millions of numbers they do more. Each new number can be compared with the patterns seen before and with what followed: a sale, a conversion, a confirmed fraud. The source’s assessment is that the value of the signals rises sharply at that scale. See why valid data is not a real person.
Assessment
A phone number collected on a form is usually stored as a contact field and checked, at most, for format. It can answer far more than that: whether the line is real, how long it has existed, whether it has just changed hands, and whether the person using it is the person on the contract.
The list will lengthen. The source expects more than 30 signals within months.
The countermeasures follow below.
Countermeasures: Phone numbers checked only for format
Most businesses check a phone number for format, or at most for whether it is live. The number can answer far more, and fraud passes through the gap.
- Treat the number as evidence
A format check shows the number could exist. An HLR lookup shows whether it is live. Neither shows who holds it or whether it has just changed hands. Decide what the number has to prove for your purpose, then choose the signals that prove it.
- For lead generation: live status and subscriber name
Start with an HLR lookup, because you need to know whether the number is live. Add the subscriber name match. Depending on the intent behind the lead, check the suppression register. For high-intent leads, consider a contract type check: pay as you go or pay monthly.
- Before KYC: SIM swap, exact age, subscriber name
These cost less than a KYC check and run ahead of it. SIM swap first. Then the exact date of birth match, which is real corroboration because the network holds the date. Then subscriber name.
- For fraud: SIM swap, out of network, subscriber name
A recent SIM swap, a number that is out of network and a subscriber name that does not match are the three to run first.
- Run the cheapest check first
Order the checks by cost. Each record that drops out early saves the price of every check after it. Sometimes the HLR result alone is enough. Combine number checks with fraud detection on the submission metadata, run the extra checks only where something looks suspicious, and send the rest straight to KYC. The best route comes from several elements working together.
- Recheck out of network numbers, then reject
A form can only accept the number at the time. Rejecting it turns away someone whose mobile is their only phone, and asking for a second number adds friction. Accept it. Recheck it three times over 16 hours. Reject what has not come back. Use email in the meantime if you hold an address.
- Step up after a recent SIM or device swap
The published SIM Swap standard looks back 240 hours by default, which is ten days, and can look back up to 100 days. Treat a swap inside that window as a reason to check further, not as proof of fraud. Do not send a security code by text to that number. Confirm the person another way first.
- Recheck stored numbers before using them
A number can pass to a new subscriber without ever going dead. Check for recycling whenever a stored number is about to be used, or every six months.
- Cover the gaps in network KYC
Mobile network KYC does not reach pay-as-you-go numbers or every smaller network. Credit file checks have very wide coverage and do not need a phone number. The number can also be used for reverse enrichment, to return the details held against it.
- Read the batch
Signs of a bad source across many numbers: a high share that are absent, out of network or dead. Subscriber names that do not match. Breach exposure, though this is far less common on numbers than on email addresses. Ranges real people rarely use, such as 070. Temporary numbers. Lists made up of pay-as-you-go numbers.
What does not work
- A format checkShows the number could exist. Nothing more.
- A live HLR resultShows the line is active. Not who holds it.
- A code sent by textShows that someone received it. After a SIM swap or a recycled number, that is the wrong person.
- Dialling until it connectsA number still out of network after 16 hours has about a 7% chance of coming back.
- A passed checkPassing a check does not make data valid. Nothing is valid until it is proven to be.
Limits
Not every signal exists in every country or on every network. Pay-as-you-go numbers and smaller networks are often not covered. Many signals need permission and the subscriber’s consent. And a signal prompts a question. It is not a verdict.
Example checks
- format
- valid
- type
- mobile
- hlr
- live
- subscriber name
- no match
- sim swap
- 2 days ago
- tenure
- 9 days
- contract
- pay as you go
Example checks are illustrative. They are not real records.
Operational resources
Relevant services and organisations that can help implement these countermeasures.
Provero was founded by Simon Delaney, who produces The Verification Files.
- Number statusProvero: HLR phone verification
Returns whether a mobile number is live, dead or out of network, and which network serves it. It does not confirm who holds the number. It returns none of the subscriber signals below.
Supports: Live status in 02. Out of network in 04 and 06. Rechecking stored numbers in 08.
- Subscriber checks
Three separate checks against the mobile network’s record of the subscriber. Each answers one question. A match is not proof of who is using the number.
Provero: Mobile network KYCName, date of birth and address against the subscriber record. UK and Spain, mainly contract numbers.
Provero: Age-to-mobile-number checkA stated date of birth against the subscriber record, as an exact date or as an age. It does not return the date held.
Provero: SIM swap detectionWhether the SIM behind a UK number changed within a set period. SIM changes only, not device changes.
Supports: Subscriber name in 02, 03 and 04. Exact age in 03. SIM swap in 03 and 04, and the step-up in 07.
- SequencingProvero: KYC waterfall
Runs the cheaper screening first, then mobile network KYC, then credit file KYC, each only when more evidence is needed. Matching details do not confirm that the person entering them is the genuine applicant.
Supports: The order of checks in 05.
A resource is one way to carry out a countermeasure. Listing is not an endorsement. Some countermeasures may only be able to be applied via a resource. How resources are chosen
Frequently asked questions
What can you find out from a mobile number?
Up to 27 things, depending on the country, the network and the permissions held. From the number alone: country, original network, validity and type. From the network: current operator, porting history, tenure, contract type, live status, roaming, SIM and device changes, call forwarding and reachability. With consent: age, name and address matches against the operator’s records, and location checks.
What is an HLR lookup and what does it show?
An HLR lookup queries the mobile network’s register for a number. It returns the network currently hosting the number, even after the number has been moved from its original operator, and in some countries whether the number is live, dead or out of network.
What does out of network mean, and should the number be rejected?
Out of network means the number could not be reached on its network when checked. It should not be rejected at once, because it may be a person’s only contact number. It should be rechecked. In the source’s testing, a number still out of network after three checks over 16 hours had about a 7% chance of ever becoming live again.
What is mobile network KYC?
Mobile network KYC compares a name, date of birth and address with the records a mobile operator holds for the subscriber on that number. It returns true, false or a match score. The data comes from a live contract and not from a compiled database. Coverage is the limit: not every network takes part, and pay-as-you-go numbers are usually not covered.
What is a SIM swap check?
A SIM swap check reports whether the SIM for a number was recently replaced. Criminals move a victim’s number to a SIM they control to receive security codes sent by text. A recent swap before a login, a payment or an account recovery is a warning sign.
What is number recycling and why is it a risk?
Number recycling is the reassignment of a number to a new subscriber. The number never appears dead. The new holder can receive security codes and recovery messages meant for the previous one. A recycling check shows whether the number has changed hands since it was last verified.
Can a mobile number verify someone’s age?
Yes, where the operator supports it. The check asks whether the subscriber is over a stated age, such as 18 or 21, and returns true or false. A separate check confirms an exact date of birth. Neither discloses the date itself.
Which mobile number checks should a business run first?
It depends on the purpose. For lead generation: an HLR lookup for live status, then a subscriber name match. Before a KYC check: SIM swap, exact date of birth match and subscriber name. For fraud: SIM swap, out of network status and subscriber name. In each case run the cheapest check first, so that records which fail early cost nothing further.
Can anyone look up this information from a phone number?
No. Country, validity and number type can be read from the number. Most of the rest is held by the mobile operator and is released only to parties with the right agreements, for purposes such as identity verification and fraud prevention, and with the subscriber’s consent. Availability varies by country and by network.